I have great news for current homeowners, the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller index showed that US home values increased at a 13.2% annual rate on average. So homeowners continue building their wealth rapidly. This was up from 12.0% in February. The biggest winners are in Phoenix, San Diego, and Seattle, where home price rose at 20.0%, 19.1%, and 18.3% respectively. Homeowners in the Atlanta realized increases of 11.2% annualized. That ranks #17 out of the top 20 US metro areas.
While this news is great for current homeowners, it poses a challenge for homebuyers. With prices rising and the intense competition for available homes, it’s even more difficult for homebuyers to win a contract.
Recent Mortgage Blog posts have covered techniques home buyers can use to win. The strongest technique for buyers who need mortgage financing is to make offers without a financing contingency.
A Realtor recently explained to me that he now coaches his clients to make smaller down payments to keep more cash in reserve to cover potential appraisal shortfalls. Most houses Atlanta are now selling at prices higher than originally listed. But a high offer price, by itself, may not be attractive to sellers when mortgage financing is involved.
(Yes, I have used this cartoon recently, but I love the smiles on the sellers’ and their Realtor’s faces, so here it is again!!)
Here’s why, the mortgage LTV is calculated based on the lower of the contract purchase price or the appraised value. If a home appraises for lower than the contract price, the mortgage amount will be based on the LTV using the lower appraised value, not the contract price. An offer above the list price is not really convincing unless the buyer commits to cover any appraisal shortfall. And, in this rapidly appreciating market, it can be challenging for appraisal values to keep pace. The appraisers must look back in time to find comparable homes that have already closed. So appraisal values can lag market prices.
My Realtor friend has seen lower cash offers beat out higher financed offers when the financed offers did not include a commitment to cover an appraisal shortfall. So homebuyers with cash available to make larger (say 20%) down payments may want to plan to make 5% to 10% down payments and hold the remaining cash in reserve to cover a possible low appraisal.
This type of environment is VERY challenging for homebuyers who can only afford a small down payment. Buyers with only enough cash to make 5% (or less) down payments have little room to cover appraisal shortfalls. My recommendation is this, talk with parents, grandparents, and in-laws about their ability and willingness to make cash gifts in the event of a low appraisal. Blood relatives can give home buyers cash for closing. This can be a great way to help young adults with little available cash actually win in this environment.
Do you know someone who wants to buy a home in Georgia? Are they uptight thinking about this crazy market? Please refer them to me. I’ll work carefully with them and do everything a lender can do to help them win the contract.